I love Château Champlain and have stayed here before. The location and the property itself are why I want this to be my first choice in Montreal. This stay left me wishing the service matched the building.
I'm a Marriott Lifetime Platinum and Titanium Elite this year. I needed to change my reservation, so I called the day before check in. After ten minutes on hold at 8am with no answer at the front desk, I called back and had to explain to the switchboard that no one had answered. They said they would transfer me and connected me to the front desk manager. He told me he couldn't change my reservation because the system was blocked, saying "maybe because we are full?" That was bizarre, because when I went online there were plenty of rooms available in every category.
I booked the extra night myself through the app, and checked in online right away. I sent a note through the app immediately asking for a higher floor (upgrade if possible) and for my two reservations to be merged. The next day, my flight was delayed, so I messaged the hotel again to let them know. I arrived at the front desk at 9pm.
No room had been assigned to me before check in, and the notes I sent were not taken into consideration, the reservations were not merged. It seemed they just waited for me to land, and give me the last room available at 9pm, on a lower floor. The staff were pleasant but ineffective and gave me scripted answers to my requests; too full, too booked, not possible, rooms already given to other guests who had paid for upgrades - I did not want a free upgrade, just a *bit* of a higher floor. Staff were nice, but there was no thanks for my loyalty, no apology, no offer to try to fix or find a higher floor tomorrow, and no mention of lounge service or hours. To be sure, I didn't insist on an upgrade, I only asked for a higher floor (10? 11?), and I was told the hotel was too full. The only suggestion was to wait until later in the week and ask front desk again in a couple of days. I’m only here for four nights…yikes.
I'm not expecting a red carpet or a free bottle of wine. I know I'm one of many travellers. But with this level of status, and phone calls, and advance requests sent through the app, I expected some help, an acknowledgement and a bit of effort to make things work. Lounge access as an elite member is appreciated, but recognition from the front desk, even a simple thanks for repeat stays and Marriott loyalty, seems like it should be a given at this type of hotel.
Sometimes for a property to excel, the capacity of the staff to help guests has to be on par with the quality of the rooms and the architecture of the building.
The bones here are excellent, the lounge is great, and I wanted this to be my preferred spot in Montreal. But if you are an elite member wanting a tiny bit of help with your stay, wanting the staff to lean in a bit to welcome you (as a frequent traveller) this is not the property for you.