I stayed in Atelier for 5 days. In a nutshell, it was an enjoyable experience but I don't think it was worth it for a 5 star resort and I would not go back.
Positives:
- The staff was lovely, attentive and friendly.
- Everything was clean and i could notice their attention to detail in the room and in the hotel ammenities
- Lovely architecture, interior design and landscaping
- Diverse activities in the hotel. Art workshops, fitness activities, culinary, tastings. It was fun!
- I'm not a golf player but the field looked impecable.
- I was very happy with the latte art in Cafecito. I was also very happy that you could choose between different coffee beans (although all of them looked medium roast). The sweets were very nice. I tried the truffle, the bonbons (passionfruit, pistachio and hazelnut fillings), tiramisu and macarrons.
Negatives:
- The beach small and i could see some trash and poop in the ocean.
- My room was close to the bar areas, and it was noisy at night. Also, I could hear everything (you know what I mean) in the rooms close by. I'd have preferred if the rooms had better sound isolation.
- Tv had no signal for 3 days and wifi was slow one day.
- Sheets and mattress could be better.
- Maybe it's the shrinkflation, but I was expecting the food to be better tbh...I read some reviews about how amazing the food was, so my expectations were high. I visited almost all of the restaurants, except for Maria Dolores and Los Abrazos (there were no tables available in the 5 days I stayed there, which was unfortunate).
- Spa staff was a bit neglectful. They kept ignoring me and attending other guests, it was very weird, so I decided against spending money there.
Food/drink reviews:
Room service: I ordered a steak quesadilla and it was very underwhelming. I could see like 4 tiny cubes of steak inside a bland, supermarket tortilla. I also ordered nachos with chicken and again, the chicken looked canned and it was very sparse. The guacamole was fresh. The Thomas Hardy wines in the room were okay.
Beach and Pool drinks: As expected for an all inclusive resort, they were fine.
Mercado 19 Brunch: The brunch was great. I went there very early and very late in different days, and there was no difference in food quantity in the buffet for the late guests. Good selections of breads and pastries (not as fresh as I would like to but it was good), a good deli section, greens, smoked salmon (it was great!), a lot of fruit, and the juices were really good. I loved the Café de Olla, it was delicious. Overall a nice brunch.
Cala di Luna: It was my favorite restaurant in the resort. The spanakopita was delicious, very flavorful. The jamon croquette was definitely affected by the shrinkflation because I couldn't see or taste any ham inside. Shout out to Sergio, my waiter, he was very friendly and helpful. Please someone promote this guy.
El Suspiro: It was my second favorite restaurant. I loved the plaintain chips and the ceviche. The dish presentation was really nice.
Cilento: yeah...I saw some great reviews about this place and I was so disappointed. The focaccia was ok. The pizza was just sad - paler than me in the beginning of this trip. The tiramisu was not a tiramisu, it was a ladyfinger hot dog with a tiny tiny portion of cream. Amir was a nice waiter, very friendly.
Kopai: I really liked the matcha sake drink and I liked the deep fried roll with tamarind sauce. Now, the sashimi...3 very thin and small slices of salmon. When I ordered the sashimi I saw the server's face, he looked nervous. I would be too. Just take it off of the menu if you are going to serve 3 microscopic slices, it's just embarassing. The amount of cream cheese inside the rolls was also almost non existent.
Takeshi: I liked it, not bad. Their rolls were better than Kopai's and the cinnamon apple rolls with ice cream was a nice desert.
Now the bars:
Don Fernando and El Detalle were my favorite bars, very relaxing atmosphere. I loved the Amorcito Corazon drink.
Final notes:
Overall it was a nice experience and it was relaxing. It's just that when you promote your 5 star hotel as a gastronomic experience, I kind of expect a lot. Also, I found this place because it was promoted to be more quiet than other resorts in Cancun which I found to be not so true. Again, I expect a lot for 5 star hotels and I think that if this hotel was promoted as a 4 star, my rating would have been higher. Cheers.