We stayed at Ocean Allure for seven days in mid-November. First off, it’s a good, solid resort, but five stars is a stretch. We’ve been fortunate enough to stay at Xcaret Arte and Atelier, and I’d done enough research to go in with lower expectations. Even so, the service and the Privilege upgrade fell short for what we paid.
**Room and activities.** We had a Privilege Junior Suite with a partial ocean view in Building 2. I’ve never had such a large room. The view was amazing, and there was so much closet space! A few more hooks for towels would be nice. The shortest route to the Privilege restaurant took us right through a cloud of cigarette smoke. Please move the smoking area farther from the path. The main pool was lively, the entertainment team was great, and the bowling alley was so much fun.
**Privilege upgrade.** We loved having the Privilege restaurant. Christopher and Fernando were standouts, and Fernando stepped in one morning when we were getting poor service. I rarely remember names on vacation, which tells you how much he added to our experience.
After a long travel day, we were sent to someone we thought was our butler. Twenty minutes into the resort rundown came the invitation to a breakfast “meeting.” When we declined, he insisted it wasn’t a timeshare pitch. Please just be upfront about what you’re inviting people to. Both our bracelets slipped off after one day, and we were told to carry them in our pockets until they could be refastened that afternoon. At US$100 to replace one, I spent the morning worrying I’d lose it. The Privilege pool had the same loungers as the main pool, packed into a small area. A little more space and some cushions would make it feel like an upgrade.
**Resort app.** This was one of my biggest frustrations. I could never get into the app the entire week. An app is supposed to make things easier. This one was ridiculous.
**Food, drinks, and service.** Most staff were great, but once the resort got busier midweek, service at the Steakhouse and Blue Moon felt rushed and chaotic. Some days there was only one bartender at the pool bar. I felt for him because he was working so hard, but the waits were long. Mike’s Coffee House was a nice touch, though it opened at 7:30 and the line was often out the door, so I barely went. And Ocean Burger, please serve French fries with your burgers. I was expecting fries and got potato chips. Come on, a burger needs fries!
The drinks were a big disappointment. My Grey Goose martini came in a tumbler, the Old Fashioned tasted nothing like one, and I couldn’t find Aperol at any bar all week. The Blackmore Spritz tasted too much like vermouth for me. Come on, Ocean Allure, bring in the Aperol!
**Main pool.** Two co-ed stalls for the entire main pool crowd felt inadequate, and the floor needed cleaning more often. Also, gentlemen, please close the stall door. And to everyone who said there was no towel game… haha. By 9 a.m., most chairs had towels on them, and it got worse as the week went on.
If you get a great deal, I can see really enjoying this resort. We had plenty of fun, and I loved our room. We paid enough extra for Privilege that I expected the upgrade to feel more worthwhile.