I’ve traveled to many different countries and have stayed at literally hundreds of hotels and my stay at the Hyatt Wall Street was the worst. And guess what, it happened on my honey moon!
I paid $3,200 for a multi-night stay in the hotel’s premier suite because I wanted to do something special for my wife to celebrate our marriage. Unfortunately, what was supposed to be a memorable experience turned into an incredibly disappointing and stressful situation. When we arrived, we were informed that our suite was unavailable due to an alleged “leak.” The front desk claimed they had been trying to contact me, yet I received absolutely no communication whatsoever—not a single phone call, email, or text message. It later became apparent that the room had simply been given to another guest. To make matters worse, the only compensation initially offered was complimentary breakfast. I requested a refund, which was denied. I then had to contact the third-party booking website, only to have my refund request denied there as well. Because I had booked a non-refundable reservation, I was essentially left with no choice but to accept a smaller, significantly less desirable room.The following morning, I spoke with the front desk again and discovered that our original suite was occupied by another guest. I was also informed that there had been no leak. This directly contradicted the explanation we had been given upon arrival and made the entire situation feel incredibly dishonest. I also spoke with Marquin regarding a refund, and his attitude was nothing short of rude, dismissive, and condescending. There was absolutely no sense of accountability, empathy, or genuine interest in resolving the situation. What makes this experience particularly heartbreaking is that this was our first trip as a married couple. Instead of enjoying the special occasion we had planned and paid for, my wife spent our first day of marriage upset, crying, and stressed over an issue that should never have happened. After spending $3,200, I expected a level of service and hospitality that matched the price. Instead, we were met with dishonesty, poor customer service, and a complete lack of accountability. My disappointment is difficult to put into words. This experience fell far below any reasonable expectation of a four-star hotel. In my opinion, it is three stars at best. Do yourself a favor and take your business elsewhere. There are plenty of other hotels in NYC to choose from.