I really wanted to love this hotel. Unfortunately, despite its beautiful appearance and some positive aspects, there were far too many elements of our stay that left us feeling disappointed.
For context, I have never stayed in Miami before, so I have nothing to compare this experience with locally. However, I have stayed in hotels across the USA and around the world, and I can honestly say that the level of service and hospitality we experienced here was among the most disappointing.
First impressions and customer service:
From the moment we arrived, the attitude of the staff left a lot to be desired. The lady at the reception desk was neither particularly polite nor welcoming, and there was certainly no sense of warmth or hospitality.
We were then informed that a mandatory $1,000 hold would be placed on our card. This is by far the highest amount we have ever encountered at a hotel anywhere in the world, and, more importantly, there had been no prior warning of this substantial charge. The unexpected financial outlay caused us difficulties throughout our holiday. Even more frustratingly, it has now been over a week since we checked out and I am still waiting for the hold to be released. I have emailed the hotel about this and am still awaiting a response.
There was also no assistance with our luggage on arrival. We were left dragging our bags around despite being clearly visible to staff, with not one offer of help. Yet, interestingly, guests arriving in Lamborghinis, Ferraris and Corvettes appeared to receive a very different level of attention, with doors being held open and luggage promptly collected.
It was difficult not to notice the disparity in treatment. From the outset, we were left with the impression that the level of service you receive is influenced more by the perceived wealth of the guest than by the fact that everyone staying there has paid to be treated with the same courtesy and respect.
Resort fees and basic amenities:
There is a mandatory resort fee of $49 per night, on top of what is already a considerable room rate. I would genuinely like to understand what this fee covers, because several of the most basic amenities were either lacking or poorly maintained.
The biggest disappointment for me was the gym. A well maintained gym with adequate supplies should be a basic expectation of a hotel of this calibre, particularly one charging additional resort fees.
Of the seven occasions I used the gym, supplies for cleaning and sanitising equipment were available on only two. This is completely unacceptable. The hotel’s own guidance clearly instructs guests to sanitise themselves and the equipment after use, yet it fails to provide the necessary supplies to enable them to do so.
At busy times, this resulted in a crowded gym full of people sweating over equipment with no practical means of cleaning it between uses. It was genuinely unpleasant and, quite frankly, unhygienic.
In-room amenities and housekeeping:
The room itself was spacious and clean, but the in room amenities were surprisingly limited.
There was a coffee machine with two coffee pods, some tea and bottled water. That was it. Even these basic provisions were inconsistently replenished by housekeeping.
There was no milk provided, nor was there anywhere to store your own. Although a fridge was available, it was completely stocked with minibar items, and guests were not permitted to use it for their own food or drinks. Removing items from the minibar to make space apparently triggers an automatic $40 charge.
This leaves guests with very little choice and gives the impression that they are being actively encouraged to purchase everything from the hotel’s own coffee shop rather than being afforded the basic convenience of storing a few personal items.
The coffee shop – a particularly frustrating experience:
My advice to anyone staying here would be to pay very little attention to the prices displayed, because they are not representative of what you will actually pay. You need to factor in tax and a mandatory 22% gratuity, which cannot be removed, and staff will still request an additional tip on top. Declining that additional tip seemed to result in a noticeable change in attitude.
What was particularly frustrating was the complete lack of consistency in pricing. During our 10 day stay, I don’t believe I was charged the same amount twice for exactly the same order. There was no clear explanation for the differences, and on two occasions I actually refused the items because the pricing made absolutely no sense. Despite asking, nobody was willing or able to provide a clear explanation or an itemised bill.
This is not about being unwilling to pay for things. It is about transparency, consistency and basic customer service. Guests should know what they are being charged and why.
To make matters worse, during the final two days of our stay, the hotel was hosting an Adobe conference. By 9am, the coffee shop had run out of almost everything, including milk. Surely, when a hotel knows it is hosting a conference attended by hundreds of people, additional stock should be ordered in anticipation of the increased demand? It was another example of a lack of forward planning and consideration for paying guests.
The hotel, pool and rooms:
There is no denying that the hotel is beautiful internally. However, it is beginning to look tired in places, and certain areas are showing noticeable signs of wear and tear.
The adults-only pool above Ocean Social was particularly disappointing. There was sand covering the bottom of the pool, and paint was visibly peeling away in places. These are details that should be addressed and maintained, especially in a hotel positioning itself at this price point.
Our room was large, clean and had a lovely ocean view. However, the solid-walled balcony meant that you couldn’t properly sit outside and enjoy that view. The neighbouring Eden Roc, guests can sit out and appreciate the ocean, this is not an option at the higher prices Nobu.
Location:
Finally, the location is something worth considering before booking.
As another reviewer correctly pointed out, you need to factor in the additional cost of getting around Miami, on top of the hotel’s fees and the already expensive cost of visiting the city.
The hotel is quite isolated in Mid-Beach and there is very little within comfortable walking distance. You will need to rely on Uber for the majority of trips if you want to explore Miami or visit restaurants and attractions further afield.
There is a Walgreens within walking distance, and we also walked to Roasters & Toasters for breakfast on a couple of occasions. There is a Starbucks nearby, as well as some lovely evening eateries along Collins Avenue, but beyond that, you should expect to be travelling to get anywhere.
Overall verdict/
All in all, this was not the experience we had hoped for, and I certainly wouldn’t recommend this hotel based on our stay.
I appreciate that this is my first experience of a hotel in Miami, so I cannot compare it directly with other properties in the area. However, I can compare it with the many hotels I have stayed in elsewhere, and the fundamental expectations of hospitality, cleanliness, service and value for money should not be location dependent!
What disappointed me most was the feeling that almost every aspect of the experience came with an additional cost, yet even the basics were not consistently delivered. Between the substantial card hold, the resort fees, the questionable coffee shop pricing, the additional tipping expectations and the general attitude of some staff, the overall impression was one of prioritising revenue over guest experience.
My biggest criticism is that the hotel seems to have lost sight of what hospitality actually means. Every guest has paid to be there, regardless of the car they arrive in, the room they book or the tip they leave. Everyone deserves to be treated with the same courtesy, respect and level of service.